Marjorie M. Liu’s The Tangleroot Palace Hits All the Right Notes for Me — A #review!

I loved Liu’s Monstress series and wanted to try other books she has written. A very good decision! Here’s a breakdown of the stories in her new anthology, The Tangleroot Place.

Sympathy for the Bones ★★★★

This one was a reread since I didn’t realize I’d already read as part of the anthology, An Apple for the Creature. However, I figured it out but continued to read to see if I’d still like it as much as I had before. The answer? I did; I do! In the story, a witch takes in a little girl and teaches her almost everything she knows—the operative word here being, almost. I love the creepiness even though the ending was expected.

The Briar and the Rose ★★★★

Begins in a way most fairytales don’t and then turns into one that has shades of Sleeping Beauty, The Happy Prince, and Shrek! A woman falls in love with the high-end courtesan she has been hired to guard. Her client, though, is not exactly what she seems. I liked how the sweetness of the romance in this story contrasted with the brutal world it was set in.

Call Her Savage ★★★

This story reiterates being a superhero doesn’t necessarily give you a super happy life! With another female protagonist, this one who has seen too much grief, we enter an alternate timeline and stumble on a war waging between China and Britain. Our heroine is sent on a return-unlikely mission to stop China from being invaded and comes face to face with an old flame. I liked the unashamedness of the blood, gore, and violence that was part of this tale. After all, wars are bloody!

The Last Dignity of Man ★★

Here we get a male protagonist, who has been named after the iconic Superman villain. He has some weird ideas that fell flat for me. What I did like was the palpable feeling of loneliness that jumped right off the pages when I read his story.

After the Blood ★

A world-ending plague turns some people into vampires while others embrace an Amish-esque faith. There was a lot going on, but things didn’t come together well. Neither could I find out why the protagonist had the powers that she did. My least favorite of the bunch.

Where the Heart Lives ★★

More strong female characters existing on both ends of the spectrum, i.e., immortal and mortal, good and bad, magical and non-magic, and so on. When an immortal decides on a way to bring her loneliness to an end, she doesn’t think of how many mere mortal lives she’d be wrecking. Fortunately, a girl who has never had a true family of her own decides to change matters!

The Tangleroot Palace ★★★

A sort of mixture of Princess Bride and the Perfectly Arranged Married trope. I liked it, but I also wasn’t surprised by the way the story unfolded and ended.


Now that I’m looking at my ratings, I can see they are almost evenly divided. Two twos, threes, and fours, and only a single one star. But in case it’s still unclear, I really liked this collection of tales and not only because it had women front and center!


I requested this book from Tachyon Publications via Netgalley and am so glad I did!

3 responses to “Marjorie M. Liu’s The Tangleroot Palace Hits All the Right Notes for Me — A #review!”

  1. RE: Ratings

    I always kind of approach anthologies thinking I’ll get a few good stories, a few okay ones, and a few terrible ones. :0

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: